Well, I’ve mostly been busy being pregnant, but I had a new comment on this blog, which made me think, “Hmm, haven’t posted there in a while.” And how could I deprive the world of more info about the greatest apple pie known to man?!
Bobby is a HUGE fan of homemade apple pie, and I think I’d probably told him a while back that I would try to learn how to make one. So when I came across this recipe from The Noshery, I e-mailed it to him as a bit of a teaser. That was, I think, on a Tuesday, and he asked me for the REST of the week when I was going to make it. I finally set about it on Saturday morning (this was several weeks ago now), and it’s a good thing I had plenty of free time that day. The recipe took a bit longer than what I thought, mostly because I had to peel and core five pounds of apples manually, plus I didn’t plan ahead well for chilling the dough and letting the caramel and apples sit.
This recipe was a tad on the expensive side just because of the sheer amount of ingredients, plus having to buy five pounds of apples (I couldn’t find a five-pound bag anywhere and ended up buying two three-pound bags) and star anise extract. I was lucky to find golden delicious apples on sale at Publix, and I think they were perfect for the recipe … a good mix of sweet and tart.
I absolutely loved the cheddar in the dough. I’m a big fan of apples with cheese anyway, and I can’t even imagine this pie with another dough. The only part of the pie that really gave me any trouble was the caramel sauce because I let it burn a little, and it ended up extremely gooey and difficult to stir in with the apples. The taste was still fine, though, and I think I probably ended up with a less caramel-y pie, which was fine with us. I’d almost recommend going easy on the caramel sauce because the results were so good.
Even though the pie was time consuming, the end result was totally worth it. It was amazing. I’m not exaggerating. I know I made it myself, but this really may have been the best apple pie I’ve ever eaten. Bobby said it was his new favorite. The one thing I wasn’t crazy about was that it was extremely runny while it was still warm (so I basically made a giant mess trying to cut it), but even so, it was ridiculously good warm with vanilla ice cream.
So if you’ve got the time to put into it — and especially if you love apple pie like we do — definitely give this recipe a shot!






